A
shepherd
79.9
2,639 stars · MIT
Workflow Automation
Windmill leads by 11.3 · clear
A
79.9
2,639 stars · MIT
B · leads
91.2
18,618 stars · AGPL-3.0
shepherd versus Windmill is a Workflow Automation comparison assembled from public repository metrics, the license on file, and whether each product can be self-hosted. shepherd is written mainly in Python; Windmill is written mainly in Rust. The composite score is 79.9 for shepherd and 91.2 for Windmill.
Windmill has 18,618 GitHub stars to shepherd's 2,639, a gap of 15,979 (7.05×). Forks are 227 for shepherd and 1,165 for Windmill. On the log scale used inside this pair, adoption is 80 versus 100, and the fork community is 77 versus 100.
Push history: shepherd was last pushed on 09 September 2026 (69 days ago), and Windmill was last pushed on 17 November 2026 (0 days ago). Open issues stand at 13 for shepherd (0.005 per star) and 889 for Windmill (0.048 per star). Issue-health scores are 96 and 70; activity scores are 58 and 100.
shepherd is listed as MIT, which this catalog treats as a permissive grant. A company can usually ship it inside a commercial product and keep its own application code private, provided it keeps the copyright notice. Windmill is listed as AGPL-3.0, which this catalog treats as a network copyleft grant. Letting users interact with a modified copy over a network can trigger a duty to offer them the corresponding source. License scores in this pair are 96 for shepherd and 52 for Windmill. This is a procurement signal, not legal advice.
In Workflow Automation, both shepherd (2,639 stars) and Windmill (18,618 stars) are marked self-hostable. Deploy scores are 100 and 100. Running either one means you own upgrades, backups, and the license duties that follow a modified copy. Pricing labels on file: shepherd is open source, Windmill is open source.
The lead is split. shepherd is furthest ahead on license flexibility (96 to 52), while Windmill is furthest ahead on recent activity (100 to 58). Choose the dimension a rollout cannot compromise on.
Windmill finishes ahead at 91.2 against shepherd at 79.9, a 11.3 point clear margin under the published weights.
Scores are computed inside this pair only. Method and weights.
Bars are scaled within the row. Higher is stronger. Open issues are a raw count, so that row has no bar.
| Signal | shepherd | Windmill |
|---|---|---|
| GitHub stars | 2,639 | 18,618 |
| Forks | 227 | 1,165 |
| Open issues | 13 | 889 |
| Adoption | 80 | 100 |
| Activity | 58 | 100 |
| Community | 77 | 100 |
| Issue health | 96 | 70 |
| License | 96 | 52 |
| Self-hosting | 100 | 100 |
| Composite | 79.9 | 91.2 |
A runtime substrate that turns an agent's execution into a reversible, Git-like trace, so meta-agents can observe, fork, replay, and revert any run. Couples agent and environments in a copy-on-write fork ~5x faster than docker commit, with ~95% KV-cache reuse on replay. Framework built for meta-agents to supervise, optimize, and train other agents
Windmill runs scripts and approval flows as internal apps, with workers you can scale. It is used by teams that want automation closer to a developer platform than a no-code zap.
Windmill has more GitHub stars: 18,618 versus 2,639 for shepherd. The gap is 15,979 stars.
Windmill was pushed more recently: 17 November 2026 versus 09 September 2026 for shepherd. That is 69 days apart.
Yes. This catalog marks both shepherd and Windmill as self-hostable. Confirm each project's deploy docs before you plan a migration.
shepherd is listed as MIT, which this catalog treats as a permissive grant. A company can usually ship it inside a commercial product and keep its own application code private, provided it keeps the copyright notice. Windmill is listed as AGPL-3.0, which this catalog treats as a network copyleft grant. Letting users interact with a modified copy over a network can trigger a duty to offer them the corresponding source. Read both grants before you embed either codebase in a hosted product. This is not legal advice.
Windmill scores 91.2 and shepherd scores 79.9. This page calls that a clear lead for Windmill.