A · leads
immich
92.6
119,439 stars · AGPL-3.0
Self-Hosted
immich leads by 15.8 · decisive
A · leads
92.6
119,439 stars · AGPL-3.0
B
76.8
12,580 stars · license n/a
immich versus umbrel is a Self-Hosted comparison assembled from public repository metrics, the license on file, and whether each product can be self-hosted. Both projects are written mainly in TypeScript. The composite score is 92.6 for immich and 76.8 for umbrel.
immich has 119,439 GitHub stars to umbrel's 12,580, a gap of 106,859 (9.49×). Forks are 7,638 for immich and 826 for umbrel. On the log scale used inside this pair, adoption is 100 versus 81, and the fork community is 100 versus 75.
Push history: immich was last pushed on 17 November 2026 (0 days ago), and umbrel was last pushed on 03 November 2026 (14 days ago). Open issues stand at 725 for immich (0.006 per star) and 490 for umbrel (0.039 per star). Issue-health scores are 84 and 70; activity scores are 100 and 92.
immich is listed as AGPL-3.0, which this catalog treats as a network copyleft grant. Letting users interact with a modified copy over a network can trigger a duty to offer them the corresponding source. umbrel is listed as no SPDX license on file, which this catalog treats as no clear license grant in the data stored here. Public code without a license is not free to use. License scores in this pair are 52 for immich and 30 for umbrel. This is a procurement signal, not legal advice.
In Self-Hosted, both immich (119,439 stars) and umbrel (12,580 stars) are marked self-hostable. Deploy scores are 100 and 100. Running either one means you own upgrades, backups, and the license duties that follow a modified copy. Pricing labels on file: immich is open source, umbrel is unpriced in this catalog.
immich is ahead on every scored dimension that is not level. Level dimensions: self-hosting. The widest gap is fork community at 25 points (100 vs 75), and the tightest is self-hosting at 0 points (100 vs 100).
immich finishes ahead at 92.6 against umbrel at 76.8, a 15.8 point decisive margin under the published weights.
Scores are computed inside this pair only. Method and weights.
Bars are scaled within the row. Higher is stronger. Open issues are a raw count, so that row has no bar.
| Signal | immich | umbrel |
|---|---|---|
| GitHub stars | 119,439 | 12,580 |
| Forks | 7,638 | 826 |
| Open issues | 725 | 490 |
| Adoption | 100 | 81 |
| Activity | 100 | 92 |
| Community | 100 | 75 |
| Issue health | 84 | 70 |
| License | 52 | 30 |
| Self-hosting | 100 | 100 |
| Composite | 92.6 | 76.8 |
High performance self-hosted photo and video management solution.
An elegant home server OS. Run AI agents, store your files, backup your photos, and do more with over 300 apps in the Umbrel App Store.
immich has more GitHub stars: 119,439 versus 12,580 for umbrel. The gap is 106,859 stars.
immich was pushed more recently: 17 November 2026 versus 03 November 2026 for umbrel. That is 14 days apart.
Yes. This catalog marks both immich and umbrel as self-hostable. Confirm each project's deploy docs before you plan a migration.
immich is listed as AGPL-3.0, which this catalog treats as a network copyleft grant. Letting users interact with a modified copy over a network can trigger a duty to offer them the corresponding source. umbrel is listed as no SPDX license on file, which this catalog treats as no clear license grant in the data stored here. Public code without a license is not free to use. Read both grants before you embed either codebase in a hosted product. This is not legal advice.
immich scores 92.6 and umbrel scores 76.8. This page calls that a decisive lead for immich.