A · leads
immich
91.9
119,439 stars · AGPL-3.0
Self-Hosted
immich leads by 3.1 · narrow
A · leads
91.9
119,439 stars · AGPL-3.0
B
88.8
52,087 stars · AGPL-3.0
immich versus new-api is a Self-Hosted comparison assembled from public repository metrics, the license on file, and whether each product can be self-hosted. immich is written mainly in TypeScript; new-api is written mainly in Go. The composite score is 91.9 for immich and 88.8 for new-api.
immich has 119,439 GitHub stars to new-api's 52,087, a gap of 67,352 (2.29×). Forks are 7,638 for immich and 12,719 for new-api. On the log scale used inside this pair, adoption is 100 versus 93, and the fork community is 95 versus 100.
Push history: immich was last pushed on 17 November 2026 (0 days ago), and new-api was last pushed on 17 November 2026 (0 days ago). Open issues stand at 725 for immich (0.006 per star) and 1,474 for new-api (0.028 per star). Issue-health scores are 84 and 70; activity scores are 100 and 100.
Both immich and new-api are listed as AGPL-3.0. A network copyleft grant. Letting users interact with a modified copy over a network can trigger a duty to offer them the corresponding source. The license score is therefore level at 52 versus 52, and the decision moves to adoption, activity, and hosting. This is a procurement signal, not legal advice.
In Self-Hosted, both immich (119,439 stars) and new-api (52,087 stars) are marked self-hostable. Deploy scores are 100 and 100. Running either one means you own upgrades, backups, and the license duties that follow a modified copy. Pricing labels on file: immich is open source, new-api is open source.
The lead is split. immich is furthest ahead on issue health (84 to 70), while new-api is furthest ahead on fork community (100 to 95). Choose the dimension a rollout cannot compromise on.
immich finishes ahead at 91.9 against new-api at 88.8, a 3.1 point narrow margin under the published weights.
Scores are computed inside this pair only. Method and weights.
Bars are scaled within the row. Higher is stronger. Open issues are a raw count, so that row has no bar.
| Signal | immich | new-api |
|---|---|---|
| GitHub stars | 119,439 | 52,087 |
| Forks | 7,638 | 12,719 |
| Open issues | 725 | 1,474 |
| Adoption | 100 | 93 |
| Activity | 100 | 100 |
| Community | 95 | 100 |
| Issue health | 84 | 70 |
| License | 52 | 52 |
| Self-hosting | 100 | 100 |
| Composite | 91.9 | 88.8 |
High performance self-hosted photo and video management solution.
Open-source AI gateway. Self-hosted LLM gateway with OpenAI-, Claude- and Gemini-compatible APIs, model routing, access control, usage tracking and cost accounting.
immich has more GitHub stars: 119,439 versus 52,087 for new-api. The gap is 67,352 stars.
Both were last pushed on 17 November 2026.
Yes. This catalog marks both immich and new-api as self-hostable. Confirm each project's deploy docs before you plan a migration.
immich is listed as AGPL-3.0, which this catalog treats as a network copyleft grant. Letting users interact with a modified copy over a network can trigger a duty to offer them the corresponding source. new-api is listed as AGPL-3.0, which this catalog treats as a network copyleft grant. Letting users interact with a modified copy over a network can trigger a duty to offer them the corresponding source. Read both grants before you embed either codebase in a hosted product. This is not legal advice.
immich scores 91.9 and new-api scores 88.8. This page calls that a narrow lead for immich.